I went through a catastrophically nerve breaking, true life experience recently. I want to narrate it in some details here to the readers for one single reason. It is a huge warning for any elderly traveler from the developing countries like India, travelling to any of these so called foreign first world countries, which are supposed to have some of the world's best health care systems and how even a possible financial ruin may await the tourist, if he is unlucky.
It started as a very minor accident, when one of my lady co-travellers tripped, while getting off from bed ( Which incidentally was just a foot high) and landed flat on the floor with her abdomen and chest hitting the ground first . I found her writhing and turning in excruciating pain. There was no choice but to call emergency medical service and take her to a hospital. Paramedical services in Singapore are perhaps one of the best in the world. The ambulance arrived within 10 minutes of our call. Equipped with a stretcher and all the first aid equipment, the trained paramedics took the lady to the emergency within next 10 minutes and she was given immediate medical attention. The efficiency of the paramedical service is just unbelievable.
But now came the reality. For next 2 hours the lady was subjected to innumerable tests that included, X-ray imaging, CT scans and ultrasounds, blood tests. Meanwhile we waited outside anxiously. Finally one person came out and told us that she has been given sedatives and is peaceful. However from her tests, nothing is clear as yet. She might have kidney failure or some internal bleeding. She would need to be admitted in the hospital. We had no choice but to accept it.
Later we were led to the office and shown an estimate of Singapore Dollars 2900/- for the costs. We were just stunned. No tourist from a developing country like India, would have that kind of cash with him travelling abroad. I then remembered that the lady had a travel insurance policy. We were relieved and telephoned the insurance company representative, who was incidently located in Malaysia. After many telephone calls, we finally became aware that yes! The accident hospital expenses can be claimed from the insurance company but only as reimbursement. This meant that we had to settle the bills first and then later, after returning to India, try to get the claim amount subject to rules of the insurance company
I would leave it to readers to imagine that if they are similarity stuck in a foreign country like Singapore, in this situation, how would they come out of this with Singapore Dollar already reaching Rs. 46/- level? Where from would they arrange this kind of money, that too in foreign exchange, and get required treatment?
Luckily, for the lady, she could arrange the funds from her loved one relatives staying in Singapore, and in any case the accident was minor. She got released from the hospital after 2 days, with a total financial damage that could be managed. I have nothing but admiration for Singapore's efficient medical treatment system, yet I feel that whether subjecting a foreigner on a short visit, who was totally fit till few minutes ago and has been admitted because of a fall where the person was just standing on the ground itself, to CT scans and X rays within first hour of admission was itself really necessary? I am not a medical expert and leave the question to the readers.
We have a situation, where increasing number of elderly persons are now travelling abroad from countries like India. Many of them do this trip because it is their lifetime ambition. Most of these people are just middle class people, who have saved for many years to make this trip. What happens if in such a situation, where you do not know anyone around? One answer is to use credit card. But very few elders in India would have limits on their cards, which would be enough for the medical expenses abroad. I would think that this little episode really shows the heavy financial risks and a possibility of total financial ruin, the elders would be carrying on their shoulders, when travelling abroad.
I would leave the decision to the readers, but my advice is that if you are above 65, do not travel abroad, unless you have someone there, who could take care of you in such crisis situations. Otherwise stick to India only, which has many places to visit and the best part of it is that even if something unfortunate like this little episode happens, it would not ruin you financially for your life.
12 June 2013
So true, infact I will like to ponder and think that even if it were a Singapore Citizen would the be able to afford this kind of expenses since all may not be covered under insurance.ReplyDelete
My recent experiences in Malaysia have been no different. Excellent service and medical care but the costs are through the roof even for normal citizens especially in private clinics / hospitals.
Thanks for your comments
Yes. This is really a matter of great concern. In fact, in USA, you must have some medical insurance, which is also expensive.ReplyDelete
The services are great in terms of response, but the doctors in India are also no less competent in their job.
The costs are high because of litigation minded people and lawyers. I have not heard of anyone suing the doctor or hospitals for malpractice and extorting 'krores' of rupees as compensation. Such multimillion dollar suits are common here. So the doctors and hospitals are forced to conduct all kinds of tests, charge all kinds of money for staying in the hospital, because if there is any problem in the hospital, people will sue the hospitals.
To cover for such calamities, doctors, hospitals just charge humongous amounts for treatment. Not all of the money goes to hospitals or doctors either. They in turn must buy an insurance policy and so the insurance company gets the money!
Often hear about hospitals closing because they ran out of money. If insurance company has to pay when natural disasters require them to pay a lot, there is always government!
Now as far as payment, if the patient has insurance, the doctor, hospital check it and require only the difference up front. So there isn't that much of a problem. Also they freely accept credit cards. They can also check your credit and agree to send you the bill later.
My experience about staying in hospital and making payment is a classic Indian story!! It is totally aggravating, but only for a moment. After all, there is always an excuse - This is India hai bhai! That can only happen in India. It always makes me feel, why the hell should I go to India?
Thanks for your comments